I have drive Pickup Trucks my whole driving life. *9 years* So I'm still somewhat young enough to answer this question.
I test drove a 06 Civic after their redesign.
I am 6 feet tall, and the car has enough head room.
The car felt like a glove wrapped around me.
The car was very responsive and very VERY Comunicative about the vehicle/road. And the base motor was down right spunky. *going from a 05 F.150 with the 5.4 liter, that was saying something!*
The car just oozed "COOL" From that instrument cluster, felt like I was in K.I.T.T.
It looks pretty cool to.
It has a very very good crash test rating, SUPURBE Reliability, and relatibley low ownership cost. and it's easy to part ANYWHERE.
And like you mentioned, their is a HUGE Aftermarked crowd for the vehicle, even at walmart. ***I HATE THE NOISEY MUFFLERS THAT SOUND WEAK! GIVE ME A HEMI EXHAUST NOTE!***
But I am with you their. Why buy a $24,000.00 car and put $30,000.00 into it to outrun a $55,000.00 Corvette when you could just buy the Vett and keep the waranty!?!
NOW! I'm not all praise, I didn't buy it after all.
It's small! It feels great driving, but cargo room is much smaller then other cars about the same size, such as a Cobalt. *Go Chevy!* And it's a lot lower to the ground then say a Focus which made it hard to get in and out of. *Woo Hoo, I DRIVE FORD!... Escape, needed more cargo room unfortunatley... And I had to pull a trailer, a lite one.*
They are one of the top 5 most stoled/broked into vehicles in the country EVERY YEAR!
and not to mention, EVERYBODY HAS ONE!
Final counterpoint, they feel like the engineers really wanted to please you. The seats were perfect, the dash felt high quality, and the shifter was OOoooh... So sweet! It just felt like somebody stayed up at night thinking about the little details. Compared to my mom's old cavaliers, these were soild gold! The cavalier, a good car, but very cheep. Lousy ride, no feeling in the controls, lousy motor *Pre 2002's.* So even tough I'm all for Detroit, if I was to buy a small car for myself and not worrying about passengers/cargo, the Civic would be top on my list. ***I would stay away from the Corolla, to dowdy according to motor trend and car and driver .
P.S. hondab16tuner - That statment about the F.150 is not true. The Tundra did not outsell the F.150, not by a margine. The F Series *Abiet, F.250's 350's and the like also* Sell at nealry a million a year. The Tundra's sales capacity is in the 500,000 range. It may be Truck of the Year for Motor Trend, but it is not the sales champ.
Peace.